Insights

Am I Doubling Up on Income Protection?

Written by Safety Nest

The short answer

It is very common to hold income protection in more than one place without realising it, often one policy inside super and another as a retail policy. The catch is that income protection generally replaces only up to about 70% of your income, and the benefit is capped at a percentage of what you actually earn. So holding two policies usually does not let you collect more than that cap, which means a second set of premiums can be money spent for no extra payout. The good news is that a review can find any duplicates and tidy them up sensibly.

Can I claim twice if I have income protection in super and a retail policy?

Generally, no, not for more than the cap. Income protection is designed to replace a portion of your income, typically up to about 70%, so the total you can receive is tied to what you actually earn rather than to how many policies you hold. Even with cover in two places, the combined benefit is usually limited to that percentage of your income, so you would not collect two full benefits on top of each other. The exact way two policies interact depends on each policy's terms, which is why it is worth having them read together.

If I have two income protection policies, am I wasting money?

Often, yes. If both policies cover the same income and the payout is capped at a percentage of that income, the second policy may not increase what you can ever claim, while you still pay premiums on both. That is the situation we look for in a review. It does not always mean simply cancelling one, because the policies can differ in waiting periods, benefit periods and features, but it does mean checking that you are not paying twice for cover you can only use once.

Overlapping cover

You can only claim up to the cap, however many policies you hold

Income protection generally replaces only up to about 70% of your income, capped at a percentage of what you actually earn.

Where a second policy can help

  • Covering something the other policy does not
  • A different waiting period worth keeping
  • A different benefit period worth keeping
  • Features that would be hard to replace

Where a second policy may be wasted

  • Two policies covering the same income, capped at one payout
  • Paying premiums on both without extra benefit
  • Expecting more policies to stack a bigger payout
  • Cover bundled in super or a loan you forgot you held

Common misconception: "more policies means a bigger payout"

This is the false belief that catches people out. Buying a second income protection policy does not stack the payouts, because the benefit is capped at a percentage of your actual income, not multiplied by the number of policies. Two policies covering the same income generally cannot pay you more than the single cap. So the extra premiums often buy no extra payout. More cover only helps where it covers something the other policy does not.

How do I know if my bank or super already includes income protection?

Many people hold income protection without ever choosing it, because it can be bundled inside a super fund or attached to a bank or loan package. The quickest checks are your most recent super statement, which often lists any insurance and the premiums drawn from your balance, and the documentation for any bank or home loan product you hold. If you are not sure what you have, that is exactly what a review is for, because gathering the policies in one place is the only reliable way to see whether anything overlaps.

Should I combine two policies into one?

Sometimes consolidating makes sense, and sometimes keeping a specific policy is the better move. The right answer depends on the details of each policy, such as the waiting period, the benefit period, any features you would lose, and whether one policy has terms that would be hard to replace. A review can compare them side by side and identify whether consolidating, keeping one, or restructuring is the sensible path for your circumstances. This is general information, so the specifics are best worked through with an adviser.

How do I avoid paying for cover I cannot use?

Start by getting a clear picture of every policy you hold, including anything inside super or attached to a loan, then look at whether they overlap on the same income. Where there is genuine duplication, the cover can usually be consolidated so you are not paying twice. One important rule applies throughout: do not cancel any cover until replacement or remaining cover is confirmed in force, because a gap can leave you exposed and new cover can require fresh assessment. An adviser can manage that sequencing so nothing is dropped before it is safe to do so.

FAQs

Frequently asked questions

Can I claim twice if I have income protection in super and a retail policy?

Generally no, not beyond the cap. Income protection typically replaces up to about 70% of your income, and the benefit is capped at a percentage of what you actually earn, so two policies usually cannot pay you more than that cap. How they interact depends on each policy's terms.

If I have two income protection policies, am I wasting money?

Often yes, because if both cover the same income and the payout is capped, the second policy may not increase what you can claim while you still pay premiums on both. A review can confirm whether there is genuine duplication.

How do I know if my bank or super already includes income protection?

Check your latest super statement, which often lists insurance and the premiums drawn from your balance, and the documents for any bank or loan package. If you are unsure, a review can gather your policies in one place to see what you actually hold.

Should I combine two policies into one?

Sometimes, and sometimes not. It depends on each policy's waiting period, benefit period and features, so the policies should be compared side by side before deciding to consolidate, keep one or restructure.

How do I avoid paying for cover I cannot use?

Get a clear picture of every policy, including cover inside super or attached to a loan, then check for overlap on the same income. Importantly, do not cancel any cover until replacement or remaining cover is confirmed in force.

Protect your future

Protect your family's financial future

Talk to our advisers about your insurance options. We offer flexible times, so book your no-obligation online consultation today and start planning for tomorrow.